We got this for our babe, thought it looked more wind-resistant than the other varieties. It is great because she stays warm in there, even in the South Dakota wind, and on warm days you can zip the cover totally off. Easy to put on and remove, it's nice becaue you don't have to align her head with a hole like some other covers. It also has a zippered pocket, I keep a paci and hat in there so I'm not searching for them as we're running out the door. I give it 4 out of five only because on warmer days it seems like even having the warmth in the backing makes her a little uncomfortable.